Broker Check
Mastering the Art of Benchmarking: A Guide to Evaluating Your 401(k) Plan

Mastering the Art of Benchmarking: A Guide to Evaluating Your 401(k) Plan

February 19, 2024

When it comes to managing a 401(k) plan, continuous improvement is key. One indispensable tool in this journey is benchmarking – a systematic process that allows plan sponsors to assess the effectiveness and competitiveness of their retirement plans.

In this guide, we'll explore the importance of benchmarking and provide a step-by-step approach to properly evaluating a 401(k) plan.

Understanding the Significance of Benchmarking:

Benchmarking is not just a compliance requirement; it's a strategic tool that empowers plan sponsors to optimize their 401(k) plans for the benefit of both employers and employees. A well-executed benchmarking process can identify areas for improvement, ensure competitive fees, and enhance the overall success of the retirement program.

Steps to Properly Benchmark Your 401(k) Plan:

  1. Define Your Objectives: Clearly outline the goals of your benchmarking efforts. Whether you're aiming to enhance participant outcomes, optimize investment options, or ensure cost-effectiveness, having specific objectives will guide your benchmarking process.

  2. Select Appropriate Metrics: Identify key performance indicators (KPIs) that align with your objectives. Common metrics include investment performance, plan fees, participation rates, and contribution levels. The right metrics will provide a comprehensive view of your plan's effectiveness.

  3. Compare Against Industry Standards: Research industry benchmarks and norms. Compare your plan's metrics against these standards to understand how it measures up in terms of competitiveness and performance. This external perspective is key for identifying areas that may require attention.

  4. Evaluate Investment Options: Assess the performance of the plan's investment options against relevant benchmarks. Consider risk-adjusted returns, investment fees, and overall portfolio diversity. This evaluation ensures that participants have access to quality investment choices.

  5. Review Plan Fees: Transparent fee structures are essential for the success of a 401(k) plan. Compare administrative fees, investment fees, and any other costs associated with the plan. Ensure that fees align with industry averages and provide value for both employers and participants.

  6. Assess Plan Design: Evaluate the plan's design elements, such as employer contributions, matching formulas, and vesting schedules. Compare these against industry standards to ensure they align with best practices and support the desired participant outcomes.

  7. Gather Participant Feedback: Engage with plan participants to gather feedback on their experiences. Use surveys or focus groups to understand participant satisfaction, communication effectiveness, and overall engagement. Participant input provides valuable qualitative data to complement quantitative metrics.

  8. Implement Changes Based on Findings: Based on benchmarking results, develop an action plan to address areas that require improvement. Whether it's adjusting investment options, renegotiating fees, or enhancing communication strategies, proactive changes can significantly impact the success of the 401(k) plan.


Properly benchmarking a 401(k) plan is not a one-time task but an ongoing process that ensures the plan remains aligned with the evolving needs of both employers and employees.

By following a structured approach, plan sponsors can identify opportunities for improvement, maintain competitiveness, and ultimately provide a robust and valuable retirement benefit for their workforce.